Soap Gone Wrong? Troubleshooting Common Soap Making Problems

Soap Gone Wrong? Troubleshooting Common Soap Making Problems

Making handmade soap is a rewarding and creative process, but even experienced soap makers can run into issues from time to time. Whether you're a beginner or a seasoned pro, knowing how to troubleshoot common problems can save you a lot of frustration. Let’s look into some of the most frequent soap making challenges and how to fix them.

1. Soft or Sticky Soap

Problem: Your soap remains soft or sticky even after the expected curing time.

Causes and Solutions:

  • Insufficient Curing Time: Sometimes, soap simply needs more time to cure. Ensure it has a minimum of 4-6 weeks in a well-ventilated area.
  • Excess Water: If too much water was used in the recipe, the soap may take longer to harden. Try reducing the water content slightly in future batches.
  • Too Much Soft Oil: High amounts of oils like olive or castor can result in softer soap. Balance your recipe with harder oils like coconut or palm oil.
  • Humidity: High humidity can prevent soap from hardening. Try curing your soap in a less humid environment or use a dehumidifier.

2. Cracked or Crumbly Soap

Problem: Your soap has cracks or crumbles when cut.

Causes and Solutions:

  • Overheating: If your soap overheats during the saponification process, it can crack. Insulate your molds properly and avoid placing them in overly warm areas.
  • Not Enough Water: Using too little water can make the soap brittle. Stick to the recommended water-to-lye ratio.
  • Too Much Hard Oil: A high percentage of hard oils can make soap brittle. Balance with softer oils to achieve a better consistency.

3. Discoloration

Problem: Your soap changes color unexpectedly, either immediately or over time.

Causes and Solutions:

  • Fragrance Oils: Some fragrance oils can cause discoloration. Check reviews or product descriptions before using them, and perform a small test batch if you're unsure.
  • Oxidation: Natural oils can oxidize, causing discoloration. Store your oils in a cool, dark place and use fresh ingredients.
  • pH Levels: High pH levels can cause discoloration. Ensure your lye is fully dissolved and mixed properly to avoid this issue.

4. Scent Fading

Problem: The lovely scent you added to your soap fades quickly.

Causes and Solutions:

  • Evaporation: Essential oils can evaporate over time. Use fragrance oils specifically designed for soap making or use a higher concentration of essential oils.
  • Storage: Store your soap in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight to help preserve the scent.
  • Overheating: High temperatures during the curing process can cause scents to fade. Avoid insulating your soap too much or placing it in a hot area.

5. Separation

Problem: Your soap mixture separates into oily and watery layers during mixing or curing.

Causes and Solutions:

  • Insufficient Mixing: Not blending the mixture thoroughly enough can lead to separation. Use a stick blender and mix until you reach trace.
  • Wrong Temperature: Combining oils and lye at the wrong temperatures can cause separation. Aim for to be around 100-120°F when mixing. Aim for even lower temperatures if you are working with milk, sugars, honey, and etc.
  • Too Much Liquid: Excess liquid in your recipe can cause separation. Stick to tried-and-true recipes and measure ingredients accurately.

6. Soap Won’t Reach Trace

Problem: Your soap mixture stays thin and won’t thicken to trace.

Causes and Solutions:

  • Incorrect Oil Ratios: Some oils take longer to trace. Ensure you’re following a balanced recipe.
  • Temperature: Mixing at too low a temperature can slow the trace process. Keep your oils and lye solution warm.
  • Inadequate Mixing: Using a stick blender instead of a hand whisk can help you reach trace more quickly.

Final Tips for Success

  • Follow Reliable Recipes: Especially when starting out, stick to recipes from trusted sources to avoid unexpected issues.
  • Measure Accurately: Soap making is a precise science. Use a digital scale to measure all ingredients accurately.
  • Stay Patient: Soap making requires patience and practice. Don’t get discouraged by setbacks—learn from them and keep experimenting.

By understanding these common soap making problems and how to troubleshoot them, you’ll be better equipped to create beautiful, functional bars of soap every time. Happy soap making!

Like this post? Follow up on Instagram and Facebook @Anasoapco.


Back to blog